Culture

How to be sad ­­– and become happier

In the pursuit of happiness, how do we benefit from learning how to be sad, only better? A new deeply personal part-memoir and part-manifesto from journalist and bestselling author HELEN RUSSELL explains just that – and shares the tools she has discovered in her extensive exploration of this little-embraced emotion. As told to KATIE BERRINGTON

Lifestyle

In How to be Sad, Helen Russell incorporates a breadth of research on sadness from around the world, as well as the great losses and challenges she has faced in her own life. Divided into three sections, she talks readers through the importance of looking after ourselves (“It’s about not fighting our sadness, learning to lower expectations, taking time and being kind, and avoiding deprivation and excess”), reframing how we communicate (“Shaking off shame and learning to stop apologizing for feeling… because we all need to open up more when we’re sad”), and things to do when we are sad (“Taking culture ‘vitamins’ and the power of art, music and books to help when we’re feeling low; the importance of getting outside, getting active. And, finally, why doing something for someone else is the ultimate in how to be sad, well”).

“Many of us will have been raised with the assumption that ‘what we don’t talk about can’t hurt us’, and, for a long time, not talking about being sad was seen as a sign of strength,” says Russell. “But really, the opposite is true. And learning how to be sad, better, is something we need right now, more than ever.” Here, she shares some of the lessons she has learned.

Understanding the co-existence of happiness and sadness

“Having spent the past eight years researching happiness worldwide, I began to notice that many of the people I met were so obsessed with the pursuit of happiness that they were phobic of feeling sad. I’d speak to people who had just lost loved ones who would ask how they could be happy. I’d meet people who’d recently been made redundant. Or homeless. Or had a bad break-up. Who’d still ask: ‘So why aren’t I happy?’ I would try to explain that, sometimes, we need to be sad. Sadness is what we’re supposed to feel after a loss, and sorrow is the sane response when sad things happen. In a pandemic, for instance, it’s OK to feel sad. But a lot of us are conditioned to be so averse to ‘negative emotions’ that we don’t even recognize them, much less acknowledge them or give ourselves permission to feel and process them. I’ve lost count of the number of people who’ve said, ‘I just want to be happy,’ at times when this is almost impossible.

“During my research I’ve become increasingly convinced that many of us have been sold a very narrow definition of ‘happiness’ – a definition that means never being sad. Or never doing difficult things. A definition that does all of us a disservice.”

Resisting the urge to fight sadness

“Make friends with nuance and ambiguity – and learn to sit with discomfort. Many of us feel as though, if we’re not happy, we must be sad, and vice versa. But this is a particularly western approach. In East Asian cultures, studies show there is much more acceptance of the idea that, sometimes, we feel happy and sad all at once. Knowing this and recognizing the granularity of our thoughts means that we can be at peace with them – we’re not constantly lugging around a sense of unease or guilt. There is no hierarchy of sadness. We still get to be sad when we need to – so first up, we just have to stop fighting it.

“As children, we may have been told on repeat, ‘It’s OK’, ‘Don’t cry’, or ‘We just want you to be happy’. When we were scared, our parents may have told us there was nothing to be afraid of. When we felt pain, we may have been advised to be brave and smile. Children look to parents for ways to regulate their own emotions, because they don’t yet know how to do it themselves. But if caregivers don’t know either, or were never taught because the ‘bad feelings’ were anaesthetised away, then we’re in trouble. And trying to fight ‘sad’ is something many of us are taught from birth.”

During my research, I’ve become increasingly convinced that many of us have been sold a very narrow definition of ‘happiness’ – a definition that means never being sad. Or doing difficult things. A definition that does all of us a disservice

Distinguishing sadness from depression

“It’s important to distinguish between sadness and depression. Depression is a chronic mental illness that needs help. Sadness, on the other hand, can be awakening. Sadness is the temporary emotion that we all feel on occasions when we’ve been hurt, or something is wrong in our lives. It’s a message. It can tell us when something is wrong – but we have to listen. If we don’t listen, it’s more likely to tip into something else.”

Embracing crying if you can

“Charles Darwin famously denied the usefulness of tears, but Ad Vingerhoets – ‘the tear professor’ – from Tilburg University in the Netherlands has found that crying serves a hugely important purpose in reducing levels of cortisol – the stress hormone. Those who cry also experience fewer ‘negative, aggressive feelings’, such as rage and disgust, than those who don’t cry. A study from Indiana University Bloomington* found higher levels of self-esteem in criers than in their non-crying, anti-sad counterparts.”

Turning up the sad music

“Playing sad music when we’re feeling low is a perfectly healthy compulsion that makes a lot of sense! [It] can feel like a companion, foster a sense of belonging, give us identity and even help us heal, according to science. Studies show that when we’re depressed, we’re more inclined to seek out sad music. Researchers from the University of South Florida** found that depressed participants were more likely to choose sad music because it was relaxing, calming or soothing. Another study, from the University of Limerick, showed that non-depressed people also prefer sad music when blue, because sad music can ‘act like a supportive friend’ and trigger bittersweet memories. Crucially, sad music also functions as an ‘acceptable’ distraction, allowing us to escape the silence, and it feels somehow more appropriate when we’re down.

“Sad music can break the silence, while also acting as a companion in our own low mood or troubled state. It can encompass wider human suffering, give us a sense of perspective, and make us feel as though we’re not alone.”

Discovering the benefits of temporary sadness

“We will never be truly happy if we’re terrified of being sad and, as the Danish philosopher Kierkegaard said, there is ‘bliss in melancholy and sadness’. And acknowledging and accepting temporary sadness can, counterintuitively, make us happier. Researchers from the University of New South Wales in Sydney found that accepting and allowing for temporary sadness helps improve our attention to detail, increases perseverance, promotes generosity, makes us more grateful for what we have and even more clear-eyed. When we’re sad, we’re less likely to fall for ‘the halo effect’, whereby we think certain people – usually the beautiful or successful – can do no wrong. We’re also less susceptible to the ‘fundamental attribution error’ – the tendency many of us have to believe others are intentional when they make mistakes or say something wrong. When we’re sad, we’re less likely to think the worst; we are nicer, better people.”

How To Be Sad is out now

RELATED READING

*Y. Joel Wong, Jesse A. Steinfeldt, Julie R. LaFollette, and Shu-Ching Tsao. Men’s Tears: Football Players’ Evaluations of Crying Behavior. Psychology of Men & Masculinity 2011, Vol. 12, No. 4, 297–310. © 2010 American Psychological Association.

**Yoon, S., Verona, E., Schlauch, R., Schneider, S., & Rottenberg, J. (2020). Why do depressed people prefer sad music? Emotion, 20(4), 613–624.